Gellar plays Tanya Martin in Dexter: Original Sin, and is listed on IMDB as reprising her role in season 2, which airs in 2025. With no other film or TV projects to her name besides that, there wouldn't be any clashes preventing her from once again playing Buffy Summers.

A sequel series to "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" with Sarah Michelle Gellar returning appears to be nearing a pilot order at Hulu.

A pilot for a new, untitled 'Buffy' project is in the works at Hulu, PEOPLE can confirm Scoobies, grab your stakes — Buffy’s back! Over two decades after Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s final bow, a new chapter in the Buffyverse is officially in the works with the slayer herself,